Thursday, July 3, 2008

NUKE THE ......WAIT!!!! THERE IS HOPE YET!

NUKE THE ......WAIT!!!! THERE IS HOPE YET!


Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar



As described by one writer, the Indo-US nuclear deal has seen a path more tortuous than the meandering of deltaic rivers. Yet, as the Bush presidency comes to a close and the UPA government totters at the precipice of inflation and mis-governance, the Indo-US nuclear deal stands out as the one hope in the monsoon of despair. Not that it has been supported within or outside the government. For once, the Left has kept its word, at least on paper. Predictably, it has backed away from the deal when it matters the most. Thankfully, that was no surprise! Manmohan Singh's government now faces the prospect of pushing the deal down the unwilling throats of the BJP and the Left by garnering support from the third-tier parties and marginalized/regional political parties and dissenting members of various political parties. So much for a national consensus on a issue that arguably ranks as one of more important events since Independence.

Much of our argument and debate on this issue has centered around the discriminatory nature of the NSG rules, the ambiguity in the interpretation of the Hyde Act and the power it confers upon the President of US to abrogate the treaty unilaterally merely by not certifying compliance to the Congress. Our approach has been, if anything, aloof, while the US has made repeated overtures that we have misinterpreted as their overzealousness to pull us in to their ranks. Far from being constructive, we have used every tool in the bag of our politicians and bureaucrats to try and hoodwink the US in to granting ourselves a virtual 'equal' status – a status belied by our past record in nuclear compliance, intellectual property(?) and nuclear safety. I am not one who believes in the '6 month window of opportunity' rhetoric advanced by some. A deal should not be rushed through in the lame duck session of governments talking nuclear peace, especially when one government would rather not face the parliamentary vote.

Yet, the fact that we are not overtly friendly to the US need not stop us from being creative and pro-active. If we are interested in a nuclear deal with countries that pioneered and commercialized nuclear technology, we could recognize their contribution to nuclear science and peace. We could, indeed should, recognize and buy in to their nuclear technology patents if that is possible. We should sponsor conferences and join nuclear research coalitions without waiting for the formalities to conclude, perhaps without even expecting its successful conclusion. India could invite senior nuclear scientists and policy makers of IAEA and the NSG club to take part in 'Meet the Public' face-offs that pit our 'technocrats' against them at televised public meetings. (If the nuclear issue does not evoke public interest, I wonder what else will? Belles walking the ramp on the news channel?) Is our democracy limited to articles written by AERB and DAE officials that tow the official line (or, if they take the opposite line, with tacit official agreement)? Are we merely a 'cry baby' nation that seeks the attention and warmth of the developed world and suckles at its nuclear breast?

Let's do something different. Like go one step ahead of the US and nuclear club and propose a serious mechanism for nuclear disarmament - something they would rather not discuss. By that I don't mean another white paper with pious legalese of the bureaucrats raising the principles of 'Panchsheel' from the dustbin. Why not confront disarmament and commercial trade in nuclear fuel, both issues dear to us, in the nuclear deal? After all nuclear power and disarmament on one hand, and nuclear power and global warming are related if not close cousins, if you know what I mean. Let's propose a different deal – a deal that links disarmament, commercial trade in nuclear fuels and CO2 abatement goals together. Properly designed such a deal could offer nations, belonging to the nuclear club and those outside it the incentive and the flexibility to engage either in disarmament, or carbon abatement, or both, to gain the right to reprocess more fuel and/or engage in commercial nuclear trade as permitted by their resources, technology, and political leanings.

Innovative? Yes, Practical? Sure. Turns the earth greener and safer? Yes! What are we waiting for?

Thursday, June 5, 2008

The Great Indian Tamasha!

THE GREAT INDIAN TAMASHA!

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


The hot Indian summer bears down upon New Delhi remorselessly. (And we thought there was nothing worse than Police torture!) But in the air-conditioned building that houses the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, the esteemed Minister could not control his glee. Times have never been better. Imagine playing God with the various sectors of the Indian economy. In these days of rising demand for energy, the government, through its PSUs or royalty-in-kind shares, owns much gas that it rations (the correct term is 'gas allocation') to consuming industries. And pray, who else but the Minister has the power to make those delicate decisions with acumen that only comes with years of honing one's political skills?

There are, after all, many a factor to consider in allocating gas. The fertilizer sector provides a vital input to the agricultural sector – a sector that cannot be ignored lest farmers turn against the government en masse at the ballot box. But the steel industry is insistent that they be allocated gas preferentially. We are an export industry, they say. The executive from the fertilizer industry association counters it by pointing out the need for raising agricultural productivity, now wallowing in the low single digits. But steel is vital to a country's infrastructure. And if infrastructure is the mainstay of Indian economy, then gas should be offered preferentially to steel. Hmm, true indeed, but infrastructure is built over years, while elections are tomorrow. Besides, the Secretary from the Agriculture Ministry just called up to impress that fertilizer plants are built to utilize gas and must be allocated gas if agricultural targets are to be met. But fertilizer subsidy targets have already been reached and breached. Confusion confusion confusion. Time for a chai. “Arre bhai, chai lana”.

“Saab, Ratan ji se chai”!

Chai notwithstanding, the Minister is perplexed. Did GAIL respond to our directive to increase gas production? And Reliance wouldn't cooperate with more gas? Why? Why didn't the steel trade union leaders call in? I'd have allocated another 'mmscmd' to them. Ratan should know that much! And where are the fertilizer and steel plants located? Did those constituencies vote UPA? How in the world do I juggle Madam Gandhi's CMP, Manmohan's promises, Planning Commission per-capita targets, and Chidambaram's subsidy budget while currying favors with Ratan Tata and fertilizer bigwigs with this amount of gas supply? Wha....What are you suggesting? Leave gas production, pricing and 'allocation' to the market?

And take the fizz out of the 'Great Indian Tamasha'?


ps: The dust gathers on World Bank's recommendations on structural reforms in the Indian economy.

Monday, February 25, 2008

Nothing 'White' About This Milk!

Nothing 'White' About This Milk!

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


Energy prices are in the news again. That's probably the understatement of the year. Crude prices have been skyrocketing. And with it, prices of petroleum products, at least of those products not controlled by the government. As it happens, this is a particularly important caveat for industries that are 'intensive' consumers of petroleum products – especially those such as the road freight where diesel is subsidized and aviation sector where gasoline is taxed. Elsewhere, as in energy-intensive sectors characterized by government-owned or -subsidized firms competing with private firms, the net impact of government control on energy prices is not immediately apparent.

After years of government-sponsored monopoly, the milk market has finally opened up. Where there was a single all too familiar government sponsored- and supported regional milk cooperative, there are now a few inter-regional competitors. As a shareholder in one of these private competitors however, I have had mixed feelings about patronizing one or the other brand of milk. No economics textbook will dare print this, but many consumers presume that higher priced milk produced and marketed privately is superior in quality to the government-subsidized milk, despite nominally conforming to the same quality standard. Indeed, until very recently, I too followed this dictum. Lately though, I have begun wondering about my choices. As the crude rises beyond the $100 mark, I have pondered over the incentives facing private milk producers and cooperatives under a regime of differentiated prices for the power/fuel they consume during pasteurization. (Pasteurization, as you know, is mandatory, and accounts for a third or more of the cost of production). In particular, what should we expect following a hike in energy prices when private firms pay the full cost for power while cooperatives are either subsidized directly for their power consumption, or subsidized for milk production? Now I have presumed that milk from cooperatives is lower in quality even within the so called 'toned' or '3% or 6% fat' category. But, under this 'mixed' industrial structure where private players co-exist with milk cooperatives, the conventional logic about higher priced milk vended by the private producer being superior does not necessarily stand. It seems to me that private players already burdened to pay in full for their energy consumption, will seek to economize further on their pasteurization cost. On the other hand, cooperative producers not under any immediate pressure to curtail energy cost or the cost of milk production, are likely to respond less or only respond after a delay. A hike in energy prices hurts the private producer more than it does the milk cooperative. Naturally, a private producer seeks to reduce his pasteurization cost while the milk cooperative is yet indifferent. Does that mean I am better off buying milk from the cooperative when energy price rise, product quality standards notwithstanding? My suspicions are strengthened every time I taste what seems like raw milk. (In all honesty, that could be a more common, but less reported problem since most South Indians boil their pasteurized milk. I wonder though if milk producers take advantage of this practice!).

There are other, equally sobering thoughts. Like how long private milk producers can withstand the drag on their profits before succumbing. Like what happens to energy efficiency in the dairy sector if consumers switched to subsidized, lower-priced cooperative milk? Would cooperatives gain the upper hand (and even turn competitive!) by exploiting scale economies consequent to a rise in demand following a price hike by private producers in response to higher power/fuel prices? Wouldn't that be a case of perverted incentives fit for exposition in a book on regulatory economics? A case fit for our judges at the CCI!

......And, how is the stock market's answer anticipating these possibilities. Shall I call up the 11 am 'Buy or Sell' segment on NDTV Profit?


Ps: Years ago, I thought of gainfully using dairy manure for growing fodder and in organic farming. Whatever happened to that idea?

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Nothing 'Fringe' About The Fringe Benefit Tax!

Nothing 'Fringe' About The Fringe Benefit Tax!

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


Two years back FM Chidambaram proposed in his budget what was considered a 'bold' step to the left by proposing a 'Fringe Benefit Tax' (FBT) on firms. It was a surprise, though one that we should have expected of a communist-backed coalition. The FBT taxes a firm's expenses on certain categories of benefits provided to executives (one's own and clients/suppliers) in the course of business. The Fringe Benefit Tax was bitterly opposed by the industry and not only because it hurt their bottom line. It created a new rationale for taxation that could be copied in other countries. It forced firms to monitor expenses that they considered 'on the house', so to say. More than anything else, it smacked of government intervention in matters considered privy by the company. After all, offering fringe benefits to one's executives and clients is an entirely private decision of the company. Or, is it?

What are the incentives of firms with regard to this expense category? I am no company economist (at least not yet, and after this column, never!), but it seems to me that those incentives depend on ownership structure, manager incentives and the type of industry. A private company in which all economic profits flow to the owners will likely seek to minimize expenses, including benefits to its managers and employees. Thus, fringe benefits if any, are likely necessary and competitive with those required to retain managers and employees. But what are the incentives elsewhere, in particular, in publicly-held companies traded on stock exchanges? Executives in publicly-traded companies are answerable to majority stockholders who tend to be mutual funds, HNIs, and FIIs besides the original promoters. Their compensation package is not a rigid Rs X lakhs per years; rather, it is a combination of a base pay, incentive pay and various fringe benefits. While the incentives are most commonly bonuses and stock options for executives, benefits take various forms - from company-provided residence and vehicle, membership in posh clubs, cruises and lavish vacation in foreign countries billed as 'business trip', to exotics that I dare not even think off lest I have a heart attack from jealousy! Jealousy aside, do these firms, their executives and managers have any incentive to self-aggrandize each other with 'fringe benefits'? In a booming stock market, or conversely, in a market down on account of extraneous reasons, do promoters (who serve as executives in firms with low public ownership) and managers have an incentive to pad up cost to under-report profits so they may add some comfort to their stressful lives? Why should they work their butts off so Prasad Rao may short the company stock and make his 4-figure getaway (and why should my executives suffer if the market crashed on account of sub-prime losses half-way across the world)?!!! I suspect there is, though the extent to which executives and managers in the higher echelons of the company engage in such nefarious, hard to detect practices depends on the firm's management tenets, 'auditorial scrutiny' and the degree of competition in the industry. The problem of illegal fringe benefits is likely more prevalent in industries with economic rents (whether on account of oligopoly, patents or regulatory price protection) than in intensely-competitive industries. Then, again, fringe benefits might camouflage so many other illegal payments – illegal considerations to competitors, suppliers and customers, even good times that are bestowed upon government and regulatory officials when they visit factories, or even implicit sharing of vacations with policy-makers at conferences ... the list is endless.

Anyway, it is this suspicion regarding the incentives behind these 'on the house' expenses that can be readily explained off as business expenses necessary to retain clients/talent that underlies my support of the FBT. As I write, the FBT is under the proverbial guillotine; its fate hanging in balance ('No FBT' or your scalp!). Knowing human greed and urges though, and the disdain with which the retail shareholders are treated with, I'd argue that the FBT is not a bad idea that helps the government and the public keep a tab on the degree of self- and -mutual aggrandizement/appeasement that promoters and managers engage in. In a country with endemic poverty, where many a poor live off the dividends and stock price appreciation, a tax on 'luxury' expenditures by firms is, in my opinion, eminently justifiable. It even serves a social purpose by forcing firms to monitor and account for FBT expenses. The FBT provides the shareholders an additional handle with which to question the performance of their firm. An FBT tax necessitates record-keeping that could help monitor corruption and evaluate executive performance; it would facilitate comparison of firms within or across industries. And it opens a little 'wiggle room' for the FM in his otherwise cash-strapped budget.

I'd vote for the FBT!

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Damn Our Environmental Commons?

Damn Our Environmental Commons?

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar

English language has many phrases. 'Necessity is the mother of invention' is one all of us have heard of. But, as necessary as environmental remediation is, there is no invention, little interest and certainly no action to speak of. Many rivers in India – choking with garbage and untreated sewage - are the dying testament to this observation. One would presume cities – the hub of economic activity of modern India – are endowed with resources sufficient to maintain their environs. One presumes wrong. In developed countries, lakes and river banks are prime property, protected either by the governing authority as parks and playgrounds or taken over by private developers to build luxury villas and residential enclaves. But, in our cities and towns, the converse reigns true. Our lakes and rivers are choked with garbage of all sorts over and above the untreated or half-treated sewage. Household waste, industrial waste, used tyres, plastic waste, dead dogs, pruned waste from the butcher shop – you name it, it's there dumped by the lake or choking the river channel. They say there is a silver lining to every cloud. Indeed, our water bodies may now qualify for funding from both the solid waste and the effluent monitoring authorities!

It's not as if we the citizens of India do not notice what is happening around us. Stench? Yeah, it does stink, but it's transitory and barely noticeable if one turns up the car windows. (Besides, who opens the window during summers?!). Lakes? Lakes we fill with garbage because that removes them from zoning laws and the grips of environmentalists. Spread a layer of earth; lo and behold, it is prime property for raising a multi-storied building! As for the groundwater, ...hey, don't you have anything better to do? Being a coastal city, these issues do not matter as much to Chennai, because the river flows in to the ocean and the oceans are recognized dumping zones internationally(!). But, consider the plight of villages, towns and cities that lie downstream of cities on major inland rivers like the Ganges. How do these population congregations live with the knowledge that untreated sewage, carcinogenic chemicals and industrial waste, household garbage and bodies are let in to the river upstream? Does anyone use water from or waddle in these rivers? Seriously though, is there any hope for these rivers and these communities?

There is, but only if we care. We all pay property taxes and sewerage fees. But it is the rule rather than the exception that the funds collected are siphoned away, mis-utilized or otherwise inadequate on account of low rates or insufficient coverage. Corruption aside, could we bring about a change in policy instrument that achieves the desired goal? Sadly, public ownership has a demonstrated track record of failure in the stewardship of environmental and public goods – at least in developing countries. Hence, a publicly elected body, with all its politics and interference, is unlikely to safeguard public resources. Private stewardship, on the other hand, if properly designed, could bring about the desired result. Environmental protection and restoration is a particularly expensive activity. It requires dedicated funds collected as user charges (that induce users to conserve on their use of the 'free' public good/convenience). If we could ensure every household, every business and every industry pays a user fee for its solid waste and effluent discharge in proportion to the damage (in other words, a variable, and not a flat tax), the revenues so collected might just open up opportunities to transform our urbs and suburbs. Private companies could be asked to bid to maintain lake bodies and stretches of rivers for an annual fee. Bidders indicate the extent to which they intend to protect the public resource, penalty acceptable in case of default, and their bid. The evaluation committee comprised of community members, officials, and environmentalists would evaluate bids while cognizant of tax revenues and the degree of environmental protection desired. The low/lowest bidder is then handed charge of the public resource for which it is paid regularly following a certification of compliance by a committee constituted of government officials, environmental and community activists. The private firm will zealously guard the resource to ensure its revenue stream and its survival in the environmental protection market. It could invoke police action on illegal garbage dumpers and sue them in court. It could, conceivably, even dam sewage flowing in to the river in its jurisdiction, forcing the upstream authority to resolve the environmental problem or pay up. Sounds impractical? Grow up. Such innovative, if draconian measures, just might be what the doctor ordered to reverse the tide of degradation of our 'environment commons'. (unless, of course, you prefer plague and other air- and water-borne communicable afflictions permeating in our schools)

Where there is a will, there is a way.

Thursday, February 7, 2008

Jobs, Jobs, More Jobs!

Jobs, Jobs, More Jobs!


Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


No matter which part of the world you are in, you hear the same refrain from politicians – Creating and sustaining employment. That they focus on jobs almost to the exclusion of anything else is understandable. Sustained employment is the source of livelihood of the masses. And the masses can be very rude at the polls if their purse is thin or they don't have a job on voting day! But much as jobs are today the visible sign of economic prosperity, should they be the only focus of our politicians? In fact, should job-creation even be on the politician's agenda?

Micro- and macro-economists see jobs as part of a larger picture in which a firm or a nation produces an (array) of outputs with several inputs of which labor is but one. The demand for labor and the change in it - which is what employment and job growth/loss measure - is itself derived from demand for products or aggregate economic activity. So, should we not instead worry about aggregate economic activity? A short-sighted, horse-blinded focus on jobs detracts from the larger task of maximizing the economy's growth. Besides, in socialist economies such as ours, a focus on employment - in particular a combination of labor-intensive policies and job quotas and reservations - will detract from profit maximization and turn our enterprises bloated with unqualified labor. Such unabashed support for maximizing employment has other micro- and macro-economic implications as well. First, firms are over-staffed and inefficient on account of a biased capital-labor ratio. Labor-intensive technologies and industries are favored over capital-intensive technologies. Second, the pressure to retain employees biases hours of employment, economics of production, and on a macro-economic scale, wages, the age of retirement, pension funding and even the labor-leisure trade-off. Third, cost-reducing technological innovation such as robotic automation and nano-technology have brought about new scale-economies in high-technology industries. Harping on labor-intensive policies excludes our economy from these advances, turns the clock of economic progress back and reduces our productivity, and in turn, international competitiveness.

These impacts are not necessarily anticipated (or for that matter, appreciated) by politicians with sights fixed for the day after elections. Come to think of it, there may be a 'political rate of unemployment' depending on who is in power, (while we measure the 'natural rate of unemployment' on the Phillips curve with 3SLS instruments)! In fact, the drama turns in to a comedy (I call it a tragedy) when unemployment and job growth are used as leverages by politicians conspiring with the industry (and labor unions?) to divert scarce public resources in to private investments that milk profits under the shelter of tax holidays in the guise of generating jobs for locals. In the days of yore when our country lacked investment, such policies could be passed off as part of the larger cause of nation-building. But in an increasingly competitive world, India can no longer afford its politicians ruining the financial state of the nation by promising jobs and subsidizing labor-intensive industries that play the petty, if enriching game. It is time our politicians desist from such ruinous practices in the interest of the nation - and for our voters and union leaders to understand that lop-sided emphasis on creating jobs could, paradoxically, hurt them in the long-run. If you ask me, there is no better time to reform labor laws, job reservations and the politician's mindset than when the economy is booming and job demand high.

Those who wish to second the motion, raise your hands.

Sunday, February 3, 2008

Insurance Humor, Huh?

Insurance Humor, Huh?

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


It's been long since I wrote a humor column. Guess times have not been easy. So what makes me write one today? Did I chance upon a winning lottery ticket? Did someone claim Indian roads to be safe or clean? Did I hear a politician make a promise at an election rally? Or, did someone claim India was a democracy? Thankfully no! What got me thinking on the lighter side is the racket called 'insurance'.

In the US, medical insurance coverage jostle for the top slot with the Iraq invasion in voters minds. Insurance used to be the prudent part of one's savings that went toward ensuring financial stability in times of unexpected medical burden. But what it has turned out in to is a monstrous bureaucratic quagmire that squeezes every penny of earnings beyond breakfast money so lawyers may enrich themselves fighting off medical malpractice cases foisted by Las Vegas vacation returnees. So the choice before the familyman with modest means is either pay up and live in a shack, or join the millions who forego insurance, leaving themselves at the mercy of the state and the hospital should anything wrong befall them.

We in India, and I presume in other third-world nations as well, feel no such pressure. Life runs its course inspite of all the shortcomings of our various systems. To live thru a day and return home from work is a miracle in itself. Ask any Delhiite who walks as the Blue Line screams by, the Mumbaikar hanging precariously to the door of the suburban train rushing through tunnels, or the Chennai college student grabbing a window bar on the bus and hanging on for dear life till the next traffic signal. Why even I feel thankful to be alive everytime I drink a cola! In these days of insurance-administered 'statistics', who knows where one is a 'number'. You did not disclose all your health problems? Well, then you are a 'number' on the road today! Didn't pay a disputed broadband bill? God help you when you cross the street! (unless of course, you have an engagement of the nefarious or immoral kind). Then there are those communal, religious and national duties to discharge that sometimes involve showing up in mass protests or in locations where certain risks have been 'assigned' (They need 2 bodies from union workers to sanction the wage accord, so you better show up!). With all these risks to boast of, would anyone worry at all about insuring himself? If the chances of dying in the next twelve months are higher on the streets than in a hospital bed, would anyone care to buy medical insurance? Or, undergo costly medical procedures for chronic diseases? Why I predict a dramatic fall in the price of plastic surgery in terrorist infested towns! Ain't it amazing how the priority for medical insurance fizzles away by manipulating man-made risks?

Now that should give US policymakers a pause! Wanna go the Indian way? (We even have a software that assigns numbers 'randomly'. It was commissioned by...nevermind the details)!!!!!!!

Global Warming In My Mittens!

Global Warming In My Mittens!

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


I have had this creepy feeling about global warming for a long time. The phenomenon was recognized even in the sixties and received scant attention for decades. Then, when it did, the focus was on identifying impacts and preparing for them, not solving the problem. Which brings up the slimy prospect: what if global warming is beneficial to humans, if only on balance. No one disputes the real impacts on sea level from melting of polar ice and the Greenland icecaps. Or, for that matter, the increase in frequency of anomalous weather events. The former is likely to be slow relative to the pace of human resettlement so that it doesn't pose a problem in most countries. (Crowded islands excepted). The latter is easily anticipated and partially internalized by various calamity and agriculture insurance policies. Changes in diurnal temperature patterns are anyway dwarfed by temperature changes from day to day. An increase in humidity could affect asthmatics, but they have their inhalers. Even the impacts on glacial melt rivers can be anticipated by prudent water resource management policies. Weigh against this the large areas of semi-frigid land that will open up for agriculture (for a longer part of the year, with water aplenty), the boom in stock markets anticipating higher demand for renewable energy technology and air conditioners, the reduction in fuel bills in the temperates and beyond, and the increase in rainfall (and agricultural productivity) and suddenly, at least privately, one is not too sure if all the brouhaha about global warming is worth the squeeze on the purse that would follow if we tried to reverse it! I half suspect there are those countries that have strategically positioned themselves to capture these gains from global warming.

So, humans could possibly emerge happier from global warming, especially if it is tackled with a bit of sensitivity to the poor. Does that mean all is well and we can get back to sipping tea? It all boils down to how much we care for the impacts on the plant world, the animal world and outlines of geographic features on the globe! Do we care about dogs dying in the extreme heat of the summer exacerbated by global warming and air conditioner exhaust? Does it matter that ships and ocean liners fly kites as they sail the 'northern passage'? Do we care about whales and creatures of the sea going haywire figuring out why the sea is getting warm even as it gets polluted? Does it matter that the mango tree flowers in August to yield fruit on the coldest day of January? Would it hurt your enjoyment of the symphony orchestra if the currents in the oceans turned weaker or reversed directions? Or, animals experienced altered behavior patterns and lower sperm count? Would your grandchildren care that the many biological, chemical and physical phenomena taught to us – carbon cycle, acid rain, eutrophication, desertification, migration, diurnal/seasonal phenomena, glacial melting – to name a few would be altered with unpredictable impacts on plants and animals and their interaction with the environment. Does it matter at all to our policy makers that some of these environmental impacts are essentially irreversible? Why do our leaders and strategists negotiate global warming as if it were merely a human problem? The bottom line, if you ask me, is that as much as we care about our longevity and survival, the human race gives a damn about calamitous impacts of its existence on flora, fauna and the environment (at least not until they drop in to the list of endangered species, by which time it is already too late). Our policies to date have been largely anthropocentric. Will we ever regulate for the plants and animals in Noah's ark?

And here's the frightening prospect (just between you and me). At the end of the day (a few decades from now), we may just find comfort in a hotter world in which the tropics are infested not by insects but humans, while the temperates enjoy the bounty conferred by global warming. And 'we' will suffer hotter summers from warming the world with our coal-fired utilities while 'they' profit from selling us more wheat from an expanded cultivation area and lengthened growing season? In other words, what if it is not 'global collusion', but collusion of the developed world against the developing world - a 'You Pollute For Our Second Rainbow' strategy?

Don't scratch your brains out!

Thursday, January 31, 2008

An Online Market for Easements?

AN ONLINE MARKET FOR EASEMENTS?

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


At the rate land is gobbled up by the rich, commercial establishments and real estate companies, (and looking at the exponent on the price projection) you might be excused for putting up your neighbor's land for sale and running away with the proceeds to Tonga! But seriously, in a land of a billion people, land is increasingly scarce. After all, we need land for roads, parking spaces, parks, cinema 'complexes', stadiums, malls, offices, palatial bungalows, cottages, hotels, entertainment parks – the list is endless. Look what suburban sprawl did to the US. If we followed them, there would be no rural hinterland to talk about. Even as things stand, our forest cover and our bio-diversity is being raped by an economy that only cares for GDP growth and profits at the bourses. If things continue at this pace, India will be one vast stretch of concrete interspersed with asphalt from Kargil to Kanyakumari!

Now, I am no tree hugger who would brave beheading for the cause of the environment. But, we as a nation can do more than piously recite the statistics bemoaning the loss of forest cover and bio-diversity. One of the primary tasks facing the nation is to conserve its natural heritage. We simply cannot afford to turn our green hinterlands in to SEZs where factories dump waste because the land was provided free with a 15 year tax holiday to top it. A country with a declining forest cover and disappearing fauna must pro-actively put aside land away from 'development' at the hands of our marauders. While issuing a fiat to reserve land around parks and forests would be straightforward, it would not be necessarily efficient. Land parcels are often not available contiguously or at the same time. Besides, the question of compensating owners is likely to embroil such policies in to failure.

Let us explore a market-based alternative, as sketchy and tentative as it may be. To begin with, let's propose an externality in the sense that capitalist development of land ignores the value of environmental services and passive WTP values associated with undeveloped land. Left unattended, the situation will take a turn for the worse, eventually resulting in the extermination of forest cover, and the flora and fauna contained in it. To counter this eventuality, we presume the government issues a funded mandate to increase the green cover from, say, 15% to 30% over a period of two decades. This mandate is implemented annually thru an 'conservation easement subsidy vouchers' scheme that provides subsidy for purchase of easements. The government issues a certain amount of vouchers to each state which in turn distributes it among its various districts. The district authority calls competitive bids for the vouchers. Those participating – real estate firms, individuals, national parks, conservation groups, environmental trusts and organizations bid for the subsidy vouchers. The authority issues conservation easement-cum rezoning vouchers in order of increasing subsidy bids limited by its subsidy budget. Bid winners receive the subsidy when they provide proof of land/easement purchase.

At this point, we have a demand for easements derived from the mandate, and a formal means to provide subsidy to the initial participants in the conservation easements market. What is necessary now is an online market for trading these easements across various classes of market players – commercial developers, speculators, investors, environmental trusts, national parks, conservation groups and so on. The online easements market could run parallely or as part of a traditional real estate market that trades land parcels much like one trades shares. (Easements will remain easements as long as they are traded in the easements market. A developer who seeks to purchase and convert easement for development must have it re-zoned before moving it to the 'land' section of the online market.). Easement and land prices will reflect their supply and demand as perceived by various participants in the market and their intentions/objectives. Higher demand for land development will boost easement prices, providing the necessary incentive for land holders to offer their land as easements. The scheme provides for inter-spatial, and even inter-parcel land-easement arbitrage. Thus, the market provides a dynamic equilibrium between easement prices and prices of commercial land parcels. Such arbitrage between multiple uses for easements and land is on one hand likely to reveal the shadow values associated with unpriced/unappreciated uses/services of land, and on the other bring about a dynamic equilibrium that equates marginal values across parcels of easements and land across space and time.

The 'easement voucher cum online easement–land market' could enable the nation to achieve its green cover goal flexibly at a much lower cost and at an earlier date with the voluntary participation from all stakeholders.

Saturday, January 12, 2008

Corruption, Desi style!

Corruption, Desi Style!

Ganga Prasad G. Rao
http://myprofile.cos.com/gangar


Many heads have pondered over it, much has been written on it, and many a shelves have been filled investigating it that you'd wonder what I have to add to the phenomenon of corruption - short of suggesting the use of electric eels on the corrupt with divine or better yet, satanic intervention! But seriously, is corruption merely the lubricant that turns the wheels of the economy or is it the proverbial spanner in the wheels of progress? From the farmer who must bribe the bank officer before he signs the loan papers, the widow who must borrow to bribe to receive her husband's death certificate that qualifies her for insurance, the anxious parent in two minds about bribing the Principal to secure his child's admission, to the impatient guy all too willing to part with a few big notes to the license officer to drive away with his new SUV, all are examples of how corruption pervades the daily life of commoners. But much as this corruption is pervasive in our society, should it really be the focus of our attention?

Is it passe to target retail corruption ignoring corruption at the higher levels of society and the economy? Retail corruption will always be. Much as we are warned not to tip public servants, some such as the postman, are so familiar that one is only too willing to share the festivities. And is money for a cup of tea to your garbage handler corruption? Even if it is, is it that pernicious to our economy? Shouldn't corruption be choked in the higher echelons of power? Corruption defined not necessarily by the money that changes hands, corruption that takes many hues unknown to the public – corruption of the ideals, suppression of the intelligent, the moral and the hardworking (and lately, the green and the left-leaning), corruption in the issue of industrial licenses and environmental permits, limits on (or perversely increases in) FDI investments, defence purchases, pollution regulations, rate regulations, minimum support prices, monetary policy, or deals that extend across generations or in to the family of the in-laws (We'll make sure your son-in-law is on the ONGC board). Corruption manifests in other more pernicious forms such as the accommodation of foreign suggestions in the budget and monetary policies (Can't let down the republicans and business houses who supported our stock markets). I suspect even the timing of mid-term elections are negotiable with 'those-who-should-not-be-named'! (Three cheers to the NAM!) If this is not subverting the popular mandate to secure private riches, I don't know what is.

Surely, the motives of corruption at those stratospheric levels is not the upliftment of the masses, much as such 'policies' may be portrayed to be and shown to be welfare enhancing? Should we not prioritize these instances of corruption before castigating the CVC for failure to monitor the various government agencies and bureaucrats for corrupt practices? If favors are granted by the size of the eventual payoff, then shouldn't the CVC turn its attention first to ministers and the senior policymakers who, by their policy pronouncements and regulations change the fortunes of industries? And how does one distinguish between just assignments to the deserving and sham ones meant to reward the wrong so others may follow that path? What worsens the already sordid state of affairs is that our politicians have found a way to share the spoils with all concerned – ruling party cadres, opposition party leaders, trade unions, stock market participants, the greens and the left, perhaps even the press. Who else but our politicians are capable of committing such a leap of faith – transforming a patently illegal act in to what economists term 'pareto superior' – a 'win-win' proposition for all but the true Gandhian. (And true Gandhians will always take a hit for the good of the nation!) But don't be fooled for a moment. If you are wondering whether anyone pays at all, just look around. Your child will pay dearly every time he drinks milk or switches the power on. Your grandson may be burdened at birth with mortgage loans to pay off. Your great grandchild is already sold to the devil!

'Punarjanma' anyone?